Showing posts with label Human Nature. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Human Nature. Show all posts

Tuesday, May 13, 2014

The Classics Club: The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, by Robert Louis Stevenson

(Source)
     *And here we see the rarely spotted North American Danderfluff emerging from its hole after forty three days of burrowing.  Hitherto it's been tending to its wriggling brood of responsibilities, daily putting all her energy into feeding and grooming them; but now that summer has commenced, the helpless responsibilities have matured and finally left the nest, and the Danderfluff is at liberty to explore the outside world.  Now we see her grazing off the long green stems of the blogger feed, and eagerly shedding her matted winter coat of thoughts onto the exfoliating bark of a blank post editor.  With luck, the North American Danderfluff will be a more frequent sight in the coming season.*

      Now to the Danderfluff's latest Classics Club read:

(Source)
     In The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, Gabriel John Utterson is on the hunt for a man they call "Hyde."  Not only has this mysterious figure been described as an odd, criminal type, but he appears to have some hold over Utterson's friend, Dr. Henry Jekyll.  Could he be some ghost of Jekyll's past threatening blackmail over deeds done long ago?  Utterson isn't sure.  But when Jekyll suddenly alters his will, leaving the entirety of his estate to the elusive Hyde, Utterson's uneasiness turns into head on investigation.  What he ultimately discovers will inspire a great deal of heated discussion on human nature, and will leave its mark on literature for centuries to come.

     This is one of those books I should have read long before now; there's really every reason to do so, and no reason at all not to.  It's short (just a novella for crying out loud;)  it's classic literature (complete with loony tunes adaptation;) and its author, Robert Louis Stevenson, has been gathering dust for quite some time now on my shelf of "I-really-like-their-writing...I-should-actually-read-the-stuff-they're-famous-for."  So, over the past semester I've sipped on this novella, making progress at the blazing speed of an inchworm, until finally gulping down the remaining quarter over the weekend.  And I have mixed feelings.

     I once heard Robert Louis Stevenson described as the Christian apologist who happened to be an agnostic.  This makes sense, considering his background.  According to this delightfully detailed source, Stevenson had difficulty connecting with conventional Christianity following a childhood filled with horror stories of Hell from his nurse, and a strained relationship with his Calvinist father.  Subsequently, he fell into various atheist circles at hhhand married an American chain-smoking divorcee, who happened to dabble in the occult.  However, towards the end of his life he became good friends with many of the missionaries living near his island home, and throughout his literary career made full use of an extensive knowledge of Christianity and the Bible.  It's tricky to pinpoint what he truly believed, but much of his writing fits in neatly with a Biblical worldview.  Jekyll and Hyde does just that.

     In this novella, Stevenson portrays man as a split being, with one side of nature that desires to be all that is virtuous and good, and another that craves chaos and foils our attempts at leading upright lives.  Jekyll has difficulty letting go of some of the darker portions of his lifestyle, and so concocts a serum to separate those warring forces in his soul.  Instead, he fails to fully purge the evil from his original persona, but succeeds in creating a second that is completely devoid of conscience - purely evil and destructive.  He enjoys periodically throwing off guilt and gorging in folly by hiding in Hyde's remorseless psyche, but Hyde soon begins to overtake Jekyll without the inducement of the serum.  Before long, the wild sinful side takes over completely.

(Source)
     Of course, this split personality philosophy rings quite true with the truth of the Gospel.  Paul describes in Romans 7 how though we may desire to do good, "evil is right there with [us]."  The laws of the flesh and the laws of the mind war against each other, and like a carriage tethered to two horses, the quiet desire for good will almost always be overpowered by the wild stallion of sinful nature; and the driver of the carriage struggles to control the entire operation.  But Christ delivers us from our bodily (sinful) natures, redeeming us when we fail, and giving strength to fight it in the future.  Man can't tame the beast alone, but by the grace of God, he doesn't have to.

     I love the way this story illustrates these principles; but one of the weird things about this book is the distant perspective from which it's told.  The story is narrated by a lawyer that has a curiosity in and suspicion of Jekyll and Hyde's relationship, but Mr. Utterson (and consequently, the reader) generally takes an outsider's perspective of their goings on throughout the entire story.  Very little is directly seen, as brief glimpses and accounts from minor characters are about all the reader can glean until the most telling action is relayed afterwards via Dr. Laynon and Henry Jekyll's letters.  It's a great story, but the distance with which it's observed leaves the book feeling a little dry to me.

     Much of this distance is intended to build suspense, but modern readers already know the twist; and without that mystery, the book is left missing a certain something.  Throughout the story I couldn't shake the feeling that I would enjoy this suspense exponentially more if I hadn't already known what was going on behind Jekyll's laboratory door.  I can only imagine how it much have been for first generation readers.  The story hinges heavily on suspense, and without it, the story feels a little lacking in... something...  I'm not sure what.  Maybe more character development, more philosophical discussion, more intimacy, more action, something.  The last two chapters or so do, however, give satisfactory first hand accounts of the drama that Utterson somehow managed to miss.  These are full of those otherworldly allegorical descriptions and soliloquies I knew RLS did so well, and had expected to see more of; they didn't disappoint in the slightest.  I just wanted more throughout the rest of the book.

     Whether it's movie, cartoon, or musical productions, Jekyll and Hyde is one of those books you can't escape in today's culture.  It's left a stamp on society such that no literary discussion of human nature is complete without at least a passing nod to this classic.  And for a novella that was drafted in three days straight, that is none too shabby.  Maybe it's because of its "classic" status I found myself anticipating something a little more epic; that's certainly what its legacy has gradually become.  But big ideas can grow out of little packages, and this story's idea is definitely one worth considering, even today.

Overall, did I go in with expectations set too high?  Probably.

Was it what I expected?  Maybe not.

Did I enjoy it?  Absolutely!

Tuesday, March 25, 2014

Die Welle (The Wave): A Study in Autocracy

(Source)
(Available to stream on Netflix as of 3/25/14)

         It's the first day of Rainer Wenger's class on Autocracy, and things aren't going too well.  Though they want a decent grade, his teenage students are adamant that this class is completely useless.  This sort of thing could never happen in today's German democracy.  It's impossible.  They as a society have already learned their lesson.
The wave (Die welle) theatrical one sheet image
(Source)

Wenger begs to differ.  In order to show his students the reality of how easily dictatorships are formed, the teacher decides to try something different.  Over a series of subtle changes over the course of a week, Wenger sets out to create his own autocracy, "The Wave," right there in the classroom.  And the results might even surprise him.  Based on a true story, the gritty German film Die Welle chronicles how easily dictatorships can come to thrive, and spin out of the control of their however well-meaning creators.

       I love foreign/ independent films.  There's frequently a certain realism, or at least a more gritty stylistic slant in movies made outside of the Hollywood machine.  When it comes to films made in other countries, it's also interesting to see their perspective of their world, instead of conjecture from those not a part of it.  Even though the real-life experiment on which this film is based formed in a Californian classroom in 1967, this film was set and made in modern Germany.  As we see the students discussing Hitler's rise to power from a 21st century German point of view, we really get an eerie sense of just how poignant this issue still is.  We see the scars that the Third Reich has left on their culture; but even those scars aren't enough to prevent another dictatorship from blossoming over the course of a mere business week.  The German backdrop goes to show beautifully that it's not for lack of memory that a culture will fall into the same pitfalls, but for lack of true understanding of the ingredients that make a dictatorship flourish.

     It takes very little for The Wave to flourish.  Through subtle changes in the classroom setting, Wenger pulls the students together into a confident, tightly knit group.  First, he insists they address him formally as Mr. Wenger.  Then, to "benefit each other's grades," he places the students with high grades next to low-grading students and encourages them to cheat whenever they need (in doing this, he also breaks up cliques in the group.)  In addition, they're commanded to get stand up and out of their chairs before asking a question, in order to "benefit their brain power with a jolt of fresh blood."  Sounds harsh, but during all of this, Wenger also engages each of the students individually by involving them in the creation of the group's design, be it the name, website, or logo.  Through each of his tactics (even marching drills and uniforms,) Wenger manages to take the authoritarian role of  "Fuehrer" in the group, gently stroking the students' group mentality, while simultaneously convincing them that they each have security and value in this "club."

(Source)
     Die Welle isn't just about the group as a whole, but does a great job of illustrating through the individual students how each of their personalities and backgrounds interact with The Wave.  Some, like Karo, have been raised with an independent mind, and hands-off, but caring parents.  She's used to being top dog.  It's because of her power complex and selfish pride that she is eventually rejected by the group, and becomes one of the strongest voices against The Wave.  Her boyfriend, Marco, on the other hand, has been raised by a practically non-present mother, and may or may not hold a little contempt towards Karo's lack of appreciation for her parents, and her nagging to blindly follow along to Barcelona after graduation.  He also recognizes that much of Karo's concern about The Wave stems from a personal beef with both the teacher, and the student body. As The Wave's influence begins to cross over into other parts of their academia, Marco sees a great deal of potential for what The Wave can accomplish.  It provides a sense of teamwork, camaraderie, and order that the school has never experienced before.  Marco isn't the only one who feels that way.

(Source)
          Tim is also a lost soul in search for something better.  Like Marco, he grew up alone, without family.  He's an outcast, and the wild rumors about him don't help matters either.  Before The Wave, he tried desperately to be a part of society, even going so far as distributing free drugs to gain friendship.  The rest of the students are more than happy to use him to get their fixes, but it's not until The Wave that he and the other students feel a sense of true belonging.  People are treated uniformly, and dedication to The Wave is the only trait required for acceptance.  Tim has never had anything else to live for, so when he finally finds meaning in The Wave, he devotes himself completely to it.

          As The Wave grows, it not only takes hold on the entire school, but also possesses the entire community, and even its founder.  Wenger struggles daily with his motives, and just how far he's willing to take the experiment.  His wife warns him that he's been receiving a lot of flack from the rest of the teachers; but the students are increasingly enthusiastic about the project, and Wenger is glowingly proud of his ability to get these zombie-like teenagers excited about anything, even if it is a dictatorship.  But Wenger's wife isn't just concerned about his public reputation; she's seen a change in him at home too.  Deep down, perhaps even Wenger is getting too wrapped up in his own experiment, secretly enjoying his growing power over the students.  We're made to wonder if and when he's finally going to draw the line.

       Die Welle's story line follows the classic spiral of beginning with the best intentions, and ending with the worst results.  It's mortifying to see how each personality contributes to that downward spiral, and horrifying to realize that even modern cultures might have the capacity for this behavior.  But there's a flip side to every coin.  It's near impossible to deny that autocracy offers a number of perks; through The Wave the students gorge on new found uniformity, acceptance, and equality, while finding new work ethic and cooperation in everything they do.

(Source)
     Like the students in Die Welle, we all crave group society.  Even the most introverted of us inherently find security in being a part of a collective, be it fandoms, clubs, websites, political parties, tribes, you name it.  Complete faith in and devotion to the figurehead of these groups leads to a bond and harmony among its members that can be very constructive.  Autocracies work to a certain extent; but they're also very delicate systems.  An autocracy is only as strong as it's leader; and every single one of them is bound to slip up sometime.

     The teens in Die Welle started out lost, lethargic, and in want of something more; and in the end they're left with more questions than answers.  Why does The Wave give them so much hope?  Why doesn't it work?  What can they replace it with?  Can that kind of teamwork and unity even be replaced?  They're left without answers, but the viewer can piece it together.  The Wave gave these students a purpose and a place they belonged.  It fell apart because its leader was fallible.   It can be replaced, but not by fallible systems run by fallible men or women.  If this situation is any example, I propose that if an autocracy is going to work, its fuehrer has to be completely competent in the task of ruling, completely conscious of what the members want/need, and completely constant and devoted to ruling in the interest of its members.

(Source)
     The human brain dictates the body in these three areas beautifully.  It governs competently nearly every bodily function from digestion to muscle movement with incredible precision and speed, such that all the systems work together in harmony.  It maintains consciousness and awareness of everything going on in the body by sending and receiving signals throughout our complicated nervous system.  Finally, it also constantly watches over the members of the body for their safety and well being, warning the hand where to move when it's about to be burnt by a flame, or telling the arm to shiver when it's too cold.  The human body is run by a competent, conscious, and constant fuehrer that mankind can't even begin to try to match, whether in modern societies or advanced computer systems.  Of course, the brain has hiccups sometimes, too; it's only human.  However, beginning in the first century there emerged a body with an absolutely competent, conscious, and constant head:
     For as the body is one and has many parts, and all the parts of that body, though many, are one body — so also is Christ.  For we were all baptized by one Spirit into one body — whether Jews or Greeks, whether slaves or free — and we were all made to drink of one Spirit.  (1 Corinthians 12:12-13)
The church is the one perfect dictatorship from which we can receive the society we hunger for.  All members are different, but all members work (or have the capability to work) for the whole's benefit using their individual talents.  There's fellowship, there's communion, there's a common goal, a common role model, and a common rule book.  Like in The Wave, we are called to love unconditionally, and encourage each other's strength in the faith, growing in Jesus Christ.  Like the nerves, we send messages to Him and receive instruction, correction, and comfort from His word.  We all still make mistakes, but we're also held accountable to Jesus, The perfect Head.

(Source) (Modified)
     He's the creator.  From the smallest quarks to the largest galaxies, all things were "created by Him and for Him," even giving the genetic adaptability animals would need to survive in harsh conditions.  Power, genius and foresight - completely capable.  He's infallibly omniscient.  He knows and sees all, whether physical, spiritual, or mental, visible or invisible - completely conscious.  He's relentlessly merciful.  Though He sees all, He still loves His creation despite our faults and failings we try to hide.  What dictator would descend into the lower member's dimension, live 33 years there, and finally die to cover our evil deeds, that we might be one with our creator?  But He did.  That's completely selfish love - completely constant.

     Like the students in Die Welle, we long for the security and constructive society that an autocracy can provide. We thrive for short periods of time under the rule of a dictator, but human fallibility inevitably leads to evil beyond belief.  That's sinful nature at work.  But the good news (literally, the Gospel) is that everything we long for and seek in a human dictator is found in the first and ultimate dictator, Jesus Christ.  We shouldn't seek security in dictators that will always fail us; but as Psalm 118:9 says, it is far "better to take refuge in The Lord than to trust in nobles. He has promised he will never fail us.

He is before all things,
and by Him all things hold together.
He is also the head of the body, the church;
He is the beginning,
the firstborn from the dead,
so that He might come to have
first place in everything.
(Colossians 1:17-18)

Thursday, February 13, 2014

Little Blobby Bigots: Babies, Morality, and the Tribal Instinct


          Over the last semester, my psychology professor would treat us each week to clips of 60 Minutes episodes relevant to that day's topic.  One of those that has managed to stick with me was one on the "origins of morality," or, rather, whether or not we're born with "moral compasses."

If you've got a few minutes, it's really worth seeing:

In this Yale study, babies as young as three months old were shown a puppet show, with two different puppets exhibiting either social ("nice") or antisocial ("bad") behavior.  They were then allowed to choose one of the puppets to play with.  Almost every time, the babies chose the pro-social ("nice") puppet, showing that even infants are able to differentiate between "good" and "bad" behavior, as well as recognize that good behavior is preferable.  Pretty complex for a three-month old!

Then it got strange.  In the next phase of the study, babies were given a choice of graham crackers or cheerios.  Once they had picked their treat, the babies were shown a puppet munching on the other snack.  That puppet was then put in the same puppet show from earlier, as the recipient of pro-social and anti-social behavior from two other puppets.  Soon after, the babies were given a choice between the two "inflictors."

Surprisingly, the babies now consistently preferred the anti-social ("bad") puppet that had "punished" the one with different snack preferences.  In other words, the babies approved when the puppet that was different from them was harmed.  This was explained by the behaviorists as indicative of a genetically formed "herd instinct" of treating those within our group pro-socially, while rejecting and punishing those that veer from our own behavior and preferences.  Baby tribalism.

     It's held today in many circles that man is born a perfectly moral creature, and that it's only our upbringings that ruin our moral centers.  However, this study has indicated that, at our genetic core, we're still tribal "us versus them" beings.  And, as one of the researchers noted, during moments of stress or weakness, we'll almost always revert to our instinctual self -- tribalism and all.  So, if our systems are coded this way from the beginning (or at least three months old,) and tend to stay that way whether we like it or not, where does this leave our moral core?

     If you were to ask the author of The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, he'd say that there are two sides of man: the wild, sinful side, and the good, moral side.  It's how we fight the battle between those two sides that determines who we become.  Along the same lines, if you were to look at the Bible, it would show that, though we were created as flawless beings, corruption (sin) entered because of Adam.  Subsequently, we are corrupted, imperfect creatures with genetic defects and struggles over sin.  Like Paul the apostle said:
"So I find this law at work: Although I want to do good, evil is right there with me.  For in my inner being I delight in God’s law; but I see another law at work in me, waging war against the law of my mind and making me a prisoner of the law of sin at work within me.  What a wretched man I am! Who will rescue me from this body that is subject to death?  Thanks be to God, who delivers me through Jesus Christ our Lord!" (Romans 7:21-25)
We're each born with natures that have inherent strengths and weaknesses.  But because of Christ's sacrifice, we can now be redeemed from the sinful nature we've been struggling against, Mr Hyde.

Now, if you were to ask an atheist about the "moral core," they might tell you that the same herd instinct this study has uncovered is what other people call "morality."  That pro-social behavior, they would say, is commonly mistaken as a moral core, and therefore we're still just animals with highly developed instincts.  If you were to ask C.S. Lewis, he'd say that even if there are things in our genetic makeup, inborn herd instincts, self-preservation instincts, even paternal instincts that push and pull us in different directions, the part of ourselves that governs between those instincts is the thing we call our conscious -- morality, if you will.  In Mere Christianity, he expounds on that topic:
          "For example, some people wrote to me saying, 'Isn't what you call the Moral Law simply our herd instinct and hasn't it been developed just like all our other instincts?' Now I do not deny that we may have a herd instinct: but that is not what I mean by the Moral Law. We all know what it feels like to be prompted by instinct — by mother love, or sexual instinct, or the instinct for food. It means that you feel a strong want or desire to act in a certain way. And, of course, we sometimes do feel just that sort of desire to help another person: and no doubt that desire is due to the herd instinct. But feeling a desire to help is quite different from feeling that you ought to help whether you want to or not. Supposing you hear a cry for help from a man in danger. You will probably feel two desires — one desire to give help (due to your herd instinct), the other a desire to keep out of danger (due to the instinct for self-preservation). But you will find inside you, in addition to these two impulses, a third thing which tells you that you ought to follow the impulse to help, and suppress the impulse to run away.  Now this thing that judges between two instincts, that decides which should be encouraged, cannot itself be either of them. You might as well say that the sheet of music which tells you, at a given moment, to play one note on the piano and not another, is itself one of the notes on the keyboard. The Moral Law tells us the tune we have to play: our instincts are merely the keys.

           Another way of seeing that the Moral Law is not simply one of our instincts is this. If two instincts are in conflict, and there is nothing in a creature's mind except those two instincts, obviously the stronger of the two must win. But at those moments when we are most conscious of the Moral Law, it usually seems to be telling us to side with the weaker of the two impulses. You probably want to be safe much more than you want to help the man who is drowning: but the Moral Law tells you to help him all the same. And surely it often tells us to try to make the right impulse stronger than it naturally is? I mean, we often feel it our duty to stimulate the herd instinct, by waking up our imaginations and arousing our pity and so on, so as to get up enough steam for doing the right thing. But clearly we are not acting from instinct when we set about making an instinct stronger than it is. The thing that says to you, 'Your herd instinct is asleep. Wake it up,' cannot itself be the herd instinct. The thing that tells you which note on the piano needs to be played louder cannot itself be that note."  (Mere Christianity, Chapter 2)
Lewis argues that if morality is just an instinct, why would we so frequently feel compelled to "talk" ourselves into acting upon it?  If all that works within us are various instincts, we wouldn't feel the need to strengthen certain ones.  He uses an example of self-preservation versus herding instinct.  Likewise, if we were to find ourselves acting in exclusive behavior (following our genetically encoded "us versus them" herd instinct,) it has to be something else that tells us excluding other people is inherently wrong.  Herding instincts have "good" and "bad" aspects.  But since we ultimately judge which elements of the herding instinct are "good" or "bad" morally, how can the herding instinct itself be morality?  It must be an instinct, and morality must be something else entirely.

     The Yale study has, oddly enough, confirmed that we aren't born with perfectly moral inclinations, but that our herding instinct, like so many other elements of our human/fleshly nature, can play a part in sinful behavior.  Herd instinct is something we inherit genetically, but it isn't morality itself.  Like every other thing around and in us, it can play for good or evil.  It's ultimately up to us to decide how we govern between our instincts, through our consciences -- our moral compasses.  But what a relief to know, that through God's grace, we can finally win the battle against that fleshly nature we wrestle with.
Therefore, brothers and sisters, we have an obligation—but it is not to the flesh, to live according to it.  For if you live according to the flesh, you will die; but if by the Spirit you put to death the misdeeds of the body, you will live. (Romans 8:12-13)

Saturday, October 12, 2013

The People's Princesses: A Comparison


     The parallel had been drawn before again and again, and would be drawn dozens of times over before the day was out.  As the bells gonged and all "honored guests" took their seats in the ancient abbey, thousands outside the church doors shuffled and pressed in close to each other in hopes of getting a glimpse of Kate Middleton stepping out of the limousine.  The second "People's Princess" was getting married.  For many, the wedding of an heir to the British throne was something they had already seen once before; to draw comparisons between the two events and their stars was only natural.  But even though Princess Diana and Kate Middleton may share their fashion icon statuses, their royal husbands, and even their engagement ring, their similarities really do pale in comparison to the differences in their backgrounds as well as their relationships with family and the media.


Diana and baby Harry
      Even though Diana Spencer was a part of the aristocratic Spencer family, she lived in a broken home.  Her mother maintained an extramarital affair for two years until the divorce from her father in 1969, when Diana was eight years old.  Both of her parents eventually remarried, and Diana found herself in a state of flux, alternating between homes.  She wasn't able to succeed in school, and ended up failing two Ordinary Level GCE exams, eventually dropping from two different institutions.  By the time Diana was nineteen, Prince Charles, pressured into marrying someone other than his lover, Camilla Parker Bowles, began to woo the young Diana, sister of his ex-girlfriend.  Six months later, their engagement was announced.  When asked if they were "marrying for love," Diana replied that yes, of course they were; Charles, meanwhile, quipped under his breath "whatever love means."

Miss Kate
     Catherine (now formerly) Middleton is the daughter of two working-class parents, coming from a line of coal miners and builders (hardly aristocratic.)  In 1987 her mother, Carole, started the shared family business, Party Pieces; and over time both parents were able to build the business up and send the children to exclusive schools after Kate experienced a great deal of bullying elsewhere.  Unlike Diana, Kate did attend university, where she met and befriended Prince William, Diana and Charles' eldest son.  Because she was already in a relationship at the time, they remained platonic until two years later in 2003, when they and a group of friends rented an apartment together.  Despite a very brief break-up in 2007, William finally proposed to Kate after having known her for nearly a decade.

     Both ladies were thrust into the target range of the paparazzi rather suddenly at around the same time in their lives.  But, unlike Diana, Kate had the luxury of maturing and becoming acclimated to the public life for practically nine years before jumping off the cliff of marrying into the royal family.  And unlike Prince Charles, William has, since his mother's fatal car accident, always been very wary of the press.  There seems to be, as the media has speculated over and over again, a very concerted effort on his part to be that defensive barrier between the media and those that he loves, whether it's patting Kate on the knee assuringly after a very long interview, or tugging baby George's blanket a little further up his neck when meeting the press for the first time.  Every interaction is on his terms.

Royal baby introduced to the world, as Kate Middleton, Prince William carry son outside hospital | National Post
Kate (or Catharine), George, and William: the Cambridge Family
     Between the two "People's Princesses," the stark contrast of their publicly-known histories seem to point towards a much more stable public and private life for the daughter-in-law, and hopefully, a better future for the upcoming generation in that crazy tornado of royalty. "Family means no one gets left behind or forgotten."  And though, no doubt, there are certainly private politics in the royal family that the public can never know about (we'll never see the full story), one can't ignore the tremendous benefits that a loving, supportive network can bring to anyone, princess or not.