Showing posts with label Phantom of the Opera. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Phantom of the Opera. Show all posts

Monday, November 17, 2014

The Phantom of the Opera (Original 1986 London Cast Recording)

Source
   
     I didn't intend to buy this soundtrack.

     A few weeks ago, while tromping through the local Goodwill, I happened upon a two-disc copy of the Original London Cast The Phantom of the Opera soundtrack, complete with full libretto notes.  Now, please understand that for a long time the Phantom soundtrack has been my holy grail of Goodwill finds.  Always elusive, even in the veritable graveyard of well-loved Broadway soundtracks that is our Goodwill.  But, all this time it had actually been the movie soundtrack I'd been hunting (how very blasphemous of me, though.)  Now face to face with almost exactly what I sought - but not quite the thing - my eyes involuntarily rolled.

      In the past, I'd always taken issue with Sarah Brightman and Michael Crawford's performances.  Brightman obviously had the vocal chops, but her portrayal seemed to lack the emotional gravitas for Christine to really shine; instead she always came off as just a bit self absorbed.  Crawford had the creep-factor that's so dreadfully lacking in most phantoms now, but the wavering lilt and tinny quality of his tone had always been overkill for my taste.

      But I bought the discs anyway.  The liner notes would at least be worth it.

     That afternoon, I plopped disc 1 into our 1980's CD player, turned on the stereo system, shut the door, curled up, and shut my eyes as the disc hissed at me before bursting into life.  I gave it a chance, and wow, am I glad I bought this soundtrack.  There was just something about blasting the original recording through that stereo system that caused me to step back and truly bask in those glorious sound waves booming into my eardrums.  Between the music and the vocals, the story - the whole musical came alive in a way I haven't experienced for a long time.

     The instrumentals on these discs were simply amazing.  Throughout I kept wondering why I'd never noticed various notes/chords before.  Were those even in the other tracks?  I don't know if they altered the music in later incarnations or if I was just hearing a level of detail I had never caught before, but it was marvelous.  And the cast?  I still think Crawford's Phantom had his overdone and underdone moments, Barton's Raoul was a bit stiff and whiny at times, and Brightman was still her trilly self as Christine.  But somehow none of that really mattered as it had before.  Maybe it's because of how new the musical was at the time; everything about it was just so fresh and exciting.

     I often wonder if Lloyd Webber had any inkling of how special Phantom would become over the years, or how many thousands of times it would be performed.  But after years of micro-judging every over-acted, over-sung note of every boot-leg performance I could find, all while hunched over my screeching laptop speakers, this original recording was a breath of fresh air to say the least.  I loved listening to what it was at the beginning - before there was any set formula for a good Phantom performance and before people started murdering it with bad affectation (not naming names here.)  I thoroughly enjoyed it.  So glad I didn't pass this one over.

     It's nice to go back to the beginning.

Wednesday, August 13, 2014

Selections From My Kickeraboo List: The Bucket List Tag

Behold, a sheep kicking a bucket. (source)

It seems like everyone on my blog feed has taken part in the recent (and fun, however morbid) round of Bucket List Tag, so imagine how excited I was when Hamlette tagged me as well!  As per my usual two to three to four week delay on my blog posts (ugh) I've finally gotten around to finishing it.  Time does fly (cliche, me know) but I guess that's where bucket lists come in handy.

My bucket list right now is relatively short, mainly because it's not my tendency to write anything in unless I really desperately want to accomplish it.  For me at least, this way each item carries a bit more gravitas and gives me juust that extra bit of drive to complete it.

On related note, I recently enjoyed learning from the ever useful Wikipedia about the superfluously snappy expressions "Kickeraboo" and "Kickativoo," which, despite appearances, were not invented by Dr. Seuss.  Just like "kick the bucket," they both mean "to die," but aren't actually related to the English phrase.  As far as scholars can tell, they instead stem from languages native to areas of Africa as far back as 16th century....  In any case, with those two terms now in my vocabulary, I don't think I'll ever go back to a plain old "bucket" list again.

Tag rules: list 10 items you want to do before you die, then nominate 5 bloggers to do the same.

So, here are the ten things I'd like to do before I face mortality:

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

(Source)

1.  See The Phantom of the Opera
     On West End or Broadway.  I'd really love to see this show at Her Majesty's Theatre in West End, where it debuted in 1986. But Broadway would be much more realistic for a North America native such as meself.  (Though I really resent the Phantom failing to catch Christine at the end of MOTN in the Broadway version.  Actors' safety regulations.  Boo.)

(Source)



2. Visit New Zealand
     To take in the amazing variety of landscapes.  Greenery, trees, mountains, valleys, beaches, sheep, Marmite, and all the LOTR/Narnia associated locales I can track down. (Sheep, scenery and LOTR - Is there any other New Zealand cliche I've missed?  Apologies to the kiwis.)
(Source)
3. Visit the United Kingdom
     For a niice loong time.  I've blogged before about my plans for a thorough Jane Austen tour,  but I've really dreamed for years of visiting the United Kingdom in general.  I want to take in as much scenery as possible, Austen related or not.  The history that group of islands has crammed into it never ceases to astonish me, and I can't help but think that I'd need more than a week or two to explore as much as I'd care to.  Definitely in the top 3 on my to-do list.

(Source)

4. Visit the West coast
     Of the US of A.  Whenever our family has traveled, especially to the beach, it's usually been to the eastern side of the country.  But I've always wanted to see the giant cliffs that drop down to the beach at Big Sur or thereabouts.  That side of the country seems downright alien to the likes of us.  Looks wild and exciting.



(Source)

5. Learn German
     For a number of reasons, most of them petty.

(Source)

6.  Read Jane Austen's novels
     So far, I've read five of the main six (still need to tackle Sense and Sensibility.)  Beyond that, there's still The Watsons, Sanditon, and Lady Susan.  I'd also love to sniff out some of her Juvenilia and other works.  For one of my favorite authors of all time, I want to read as many of her works as I can find




(Source)
7. Read The Lord of the Rings
     Maayybe The Silmarillion too. I'm still having a really hard time trudging through the forests in The Fellowship; and that makes me feel really uber guilty because it's amazing literature and I really do love and adore every minute of it like... wow, but then I walk away and I find it really really hard to just pick up and keep reading because darn those forests are just so thick and I just don't know.  I love you, Tolkien.  I just have a hard time.



(Source)

8. Braid a French braid
     Despite the fact that braids are supposedly healthier for hair, more often than not, my hair is left in a regular (rather damaging) bun or ponytail.  Much of this is due to the fact that my head is just about covered in cowlicks - a ponytail is hard enough as is.  But it's about time to move onto bigger and better things.  I will learn how to conquer a french braid.


(Source)

9. Work with dogs
     I love dogs.  Whenever we visit extended family or pet-sit our friends' pooches, I always find  myself trying to teach them new tricks and behaviors.  Animal behavior is definitely one of my passions, and I hope I can someday put that to good use by working with service animals.




(Source)

10. Settle down and homeschool a family
     Society at large tends to scoff at such ambitions, but that's really all I've ever wanted to do in terms of career.  There may be plenty of things to do until then, but my hope for the future has always been to have my own little brood at home.





-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

That's about it!  It's not a huge list, but one that I would (I think) feel quite satisfied were I to complete it.  Here's for hoping!

I'm also tagging:

Treskie, at Occasional Randomness
Carissa, at Musings of an Introvert
Nessima, at Arda Nessimava
Sarah, at Mi Isla
and Charity at Idle Wanderings

You're it ladies!  Thanks-so-very-much for reading.  Live long, prosper; and good luck with your "kickeraboo" lists!

Saturday, February 8, 2014

Music + Ice + Davis and White: Vancouver Loverliness



          Apparently my family (and the TiVo) missed the Olympic Ice Dancing Short Program this morning.

          So, here's for hoping that NBC will air it again this evening.  *le sigh*

          Until then, I thought it'd be fun to share some favorite ice dance performances from the Vancouver Olympics four years ago, to be more specific, those of U.S. pair Meryl Davis and Charlie White.  In 2010, they won the silver medal, sandwiched between their Canadian training mates, Tessa Virtue and Scott Moir, and Russia's Oksana Domnina and Maxim Shabalin (remember those Aboriginal dance and costumes?)  Both Virtue/Moir and Davis/White have returned for the Sochi Olympics, and the media-hyped "rivalry" continues.

          Ice dancing is a little different from figure skating in that it's modeled after actual ballroom dancing.  It incorporates and judges according to a greater artistic bent, and focuses much less on the technical jumps and acrobatics (at least, that's how I read it.)  In execution, it seems like the pairs can have a little bit more fun with the choreography and other stylistic elements. Whatever else the differences may be, the end result is really something remarkable.  Since our family first discovered ice dancing during the 2010 Winter Olympics, I've actually come to prefer it to figure skating!

          Of course, I can't speak with any authority about how good or bad an ice dancer is; all I can say is that Davis and White's performances were, by far, our favorite part of the Vancouver Winter Olympics.  The music they choose is delightful, and, unlike some teams, they have the timing, energy, and artistry to match it.  Though for the first round each team was required to dance the same piece (very neat to compare,) their round two original Indian folk dance was, if you ask me, one of the most... *cough*... original pieces during the entire competition; they really did a neat job of incorporating the Indian feel into dance itself.  For the final round, they then danced beautifully to a Phantom of the Opera medley.

Be still my heart.

YouTube won't allow me to embed these videos, but these are the links to the second and third phases, respectfully.  They're three hours a piece (!) so, to save some time, the medal-winning performances are as follows:

Ice Dance Figure Skating Full Event - Vancouver 2010 Winter Olympics (Full Event #2)

- 1:56:25 - Oksana Domnina and Maxim Shabalin, "Aboriginal dance" (Team Russia) - 1:56:25 -

- 2:04:50 - Davis and White, "Indian folk dance" (Team USA)

- 2:24:00 - Tessa Virtue and Scott Moir, "Spanish Flamenco" (Team Canada)

Figure Skating Ice Dance Full Event - Canada Gold - Vancouver 2010 Winter Olympics (Full Event #3)

- 2:33:55 - Davis and White, skating to "The Phantom of the Opera" (Team USA)

- 2:49:30 - Virtue and Moir, skating to "Symphony No 5 (G. Mahler)" (Team Canada)

- 3:05:25 - Oksana Domnina and Maxim Shabalin, skating to "The Double Life of Veronique" (Team Russia)

- 3:15:50 - Final Victory/Medal Ceremony

There are many other Davis and White performances on YouTube, for anyone that's interested (even going back to 1999 when they were little kiddos!).  I sure am hoping to see them tonight on the TV also.

I even heard they're doing a "My Fair Lady" medley.

Regardless of how Sochi's Olympic Ice Dancing competition turns out, it'll be a blast if it's anything close to what it was four years ago.  The media has been slating Davis and White for a gold this year, and while I'm not a judge of ice dancing, it seems to me that it would be a long time coming, and very well earned.  Best of luck to them!

Saturday, October 5, 2013

Symbolism in The Phantom of the Opera


     I really appreciate and love the veritable plethora of social commentary, allegories, and symbolism in The Phantom of the Opera, particularly the plight of the mentally, criminally insane genius or even the power of manipulation.  But over the years this particular thread has been one I keep coming back to and building on.  I'm not inclined in the least to think this was an intentional allegory on the part of the creator(s) of book or musical, but it's definitely become part of the lasting appeal to Phantom of the Opera, for me, anyway.

Past the point of no return,  the Final Threshold...
Ominous, no?
First... a little back-story:

     Now, a certain relative of mine has always taken issue with the fact that, at least in the movie, Christine is one weak, passive gal, and either way she chooses between Raoul and Erik she cannot WIIINNN, *ahem*.....  In all seriousness, that either way she chooses between them, she's putting herself into the hands of an overbearing alpha-male that will never give her the freedom she truly needs to be happy.  (personally, I think Raoul's protective instinct pales in comparison to Erik's controlling and obsessive need for power over her, but that's just m.h.o)  So... as we delved deeper into POTO, we took particular care to listen to the lyrics for evidences of the true nature of Raoul and Erik's respective relationships with Christine.

     It must have been during one of those early listening sessions that our mom mentioned in passing how "All I Ask of You" is not exclusively a "Raoul and Christine" song, but one that paints a really beautiful picture of any marriage; one of love, support, and caring for/protecting each other.  Even if the song itself is a little one-sided, I think it's important to remember that Raoul is trying to comfort Christine and give his promises to help save her from the solitude and terror she's been trapped by.  That's when it occurred to me that Raoul had taken on the role of a savior to Christine, just as Christ has become our own savior from the darkness and solitude that we find ourselves trapped in, our shelter, our light.

The Phantom of the Opera     Raoul was, many years ago, Christine's childhood sweetheart (is that fair to say?), but since then they have been separated, and Christine has grown up.  But now that Christine's full potential is about to be realized, she finds herself enveloped by the Phantom's threatening shadow.  Like Christ, Raoul steps in and makes a declaration of his love and intention to save her from the isolating darkness she's fallen into.  He promises to free her from her fears, and guide her back into daylight from the nightmare.
No more talk of darkness,
Forget these wide-eyed fears.
I'm here, nothing can harm you -
My words will warm and calm you. 
Let me be your freedom,
Let daylight dry your tears.
I'm here, with you, beside you,
To guard you and to guide you...  
      The Phantom, on the other hand, wants to lead her into the nightmare.  Since she was a very little girl, he's been masquerading as an angel sent to her from her father (hmm), teaching her the methods of his dark, bewitching music.  But now he reveals himself to her in her own reflection (interesting), and lures her down to his lair.  Like the devil, he wants her to serve him.  He wills her to be "his mask" to the world; "his spirit and her voice in one combined."  He tells her to turn away from the daylight, "surrender to her darkest dreams", and let his "music" "secretly possess" or own her.
Sing, My Angel of Music... by *Luaprata91 on deviantART
Let your mind start a journey through a strange, new world!
Leave all thoughts of the world you knew before!
Let your soul take you where you long to be! 
Only then can you belong to me ... 
Floating, falling, sweet intoxication!
Touch me, trust me, savor each sensation!
Let the dream begin, let your darker side give in
To the power of the music that I write
The power of the music of the night...

     After the Buquet's murder, Christine finally sees the Phantom for the danger he is and accepts Raoul's offer to help.  But following a few months Phantom-free, the Phantom suddenly emerges and lays his final trap, the opera Don Juan Triumphant (Matt 23-24.)  Raoul then lays his own trap for the Phantom during the performance.  He encourages Christine to go through with the role in order to finally overcome the Phantom, but it's not an easy task.  It's going to take a great deal of courage, determination, and faith in Raoul's plan to win, just as we need to trust fully in our own savior to overcome the grip of sin on our lives.

    When we get to "Wishing You Were Somehow Here Again", Christine comes to the point where she realizes that, in order to escape the Phantom and move on in life, she has to finally let go of her past.  That tight grip the Phantom has on her stems firmly in her need for a father figure.  Ever since she first arrived in the opera house, he's taken advantage of that hole in her heart, much like evil takes hold and uses holes in our hearts against us.  And like Christine, we have to finally let go of our past and let salvation fill those holes in order to move on.

The Phantom of The Opera by ~LibertineM on deviantART
     Though there's a whole lot going on in the Final Lair that I might want to extrapolate on later, I'm just going to focus on the basics, here.  From this point of view, the Final Lair can be seen as a sort of final test for Christine.  She's challenged to be willing to give up life as she knows it for Raoul.  The point of no return.  Even though, ultimately, Christine may not be called on to actually sacrifice herself for him, she proves her dedication to the relationship by essentially resigning herself to do what it takes for Raoul, however much it costs.  It's then that the Phantom realizes that whatever control he might have had over her before is now gone.  Even if he did trap her in his dungeon for the rest of her life, she would always love Raoul more.  The Phantom's power is gone; so he lets her go, secure in the protection that true love has given her.

     In a weird way, The Phantom of the Opera can be seen as a sort of Christian salvation story.  Of course, there are other details that don't fit as snugly into that kind of plot (i.e. circus freak brought to the opera house by Madame Giry, the ring Christine gives Erik at the end, and the whole "Christine I loooove you" spiel.) I think these really tie in more with the mentally insane, human phantom point of view, and I do enjoy them separately as part of that story-line.  The two viewpoints intermingle so much throughout the plot that it's always very engaging to untangle while watching it.  The many ways you can look at The Phantom of the Opera, in its music, its libretto, and its plot are something that make me find something new every single time I watch or listen to it.  At the end of the day, I'm always left wondering  whether or not it really is a coincidence the main heroine is named "Christine".

Friday, September 27, 2013

Because I Had to: Here's an Anthony Warlow Post...


Anthony Warlow (Daddy Warbucks) & Lilla Crawford (Annie)     In honor of Celebrate Musicals Week, today I thought it'd be fun to highlight one of our family's favorite musical performers.

     We first discovered Anthony Warlow much later than most of his fans.  His appearance (starting @ 3:23) at the end of the Phantom of the Opera 25th Anniversary Concert, however brief, led to us, well, googling some more performances of his, and that ultimately led us to becoming both Warlow, and Gilbert and Sullivan fans.  We've really enjoyed listening to the the sheer range and power of his voice, as well as his capability to add intonation, and, well, acting to his vocal performances.  He makes it look effortless.

     Anthony Warlow has played many many roles, ranging from "high opera to musical comedy".  He's especially known for his impressive impressions (sorry, had to) and wide vocal range.  A human chameleon, y'all.  Unfortunately, I'm not an Australian opera buff, so I'm not sure what exactly he's most known for, but he has played in many Gilbert and Sullivan productions with Opera Australia, from Archibald Grosvenor (Patience) and Captain Corcoran (H.M.S. Pinafore), to a Jack-Sparrow-inspired Pirate King (Pirates of Penzance), as well as Enjolras (Les Miserables), and Gabriel Eisenstien (Die Fledermaus), to his current role as Daddy Warbucks in Broadway's new "Annie" production.  So, as many things as there are to listen to, I thought it might be fun to post a few of the clips of his we've enjoyed over the past few months.

Annnd... YouTube will not cooperate with any blogging shenanigans today, so I can't put the videos on directly.  There are linkies to the videos, though, that will have to do.


     1.Love Changes Everything - I know I'm treading on ice here, since Michael Ball is generally seen as the standard for "Love Changes Everything."  Warlow's version does start out a little tame, but if you hold out till the big notes in the third verse, it's mucho worth it.

     2.When I Go Out of Door - This is from the recorded performance of Opera Australia's production of Gilbert and Sullivan's "Patience."  Warlow plays Archibald Grosvenor, an ridiculously handsome aesthetic that, though he may not be completely keen on the movement, feels it's his duty to nature to make himself as beautiful as possible, so that others may enjoy gazing upon his perfection (strange, but hey, this is G&S.)  Then the topsy-turvy goes on, and this happens.  See the wiki if you wish to spoil what's going on for yourself, or enjoy in ignorance, it works both ways; just look at that footwork! =D

     3.Trial By Jury - Another G&S performance.  Here is the finale from "Trial By Jury"; Warlow plays an old and decrepit judge that may or may not be very qualified for the job in this courtroom opera.  This is a great example of how adaptable and transformable Mr. Warlow is in many roles.  He's a chameleon, I tell you, chameleon!

     4.Confrontation (Jekyll and Hyde) - In 1994, Anthony Warlow contributed to the concept recording for the new musical "Jekyll and Hyde."  As far as I know, he's never actually played in this role on stage, but the recording of the argument between Jekyll and Hyde is just marvelous.  The way he differentiates between the "two" characters, and the tension in it is really wonderful to listen to.  Great song, great singer.  (Constantine Marules can't compare; sorry dude.)

(By the by, the pictures in the video are not Warlow, I'm guessing they came from the musical when it actually released)

     5.Bring Him Home - If you don't listen to anything else on this post, do listen to this song!  I'm not sure if Warlow has ever played Jean Valjean before, but this rendition of "Bring Him Home" is just absolutely amazing.  Hit play.  You know you want to. ;)

     So, there's some Anthony Warlow for you!  As stated before, he's quickly become a favorite in this house, and we may or may not be hoping that he'll soon choose to leave Annie, and subsequently be cast in lead role for the new North American "Phantom of the Opera" Tour.  Hey, one can hope, right?

What do y'all think?  Do you have any favorite musical performers?

Thursday, September 26, 2013

In Regard to Monsieur Butler....


     I know my family is part of a very very small minority in that we don't mind, even like, even, yeah... love Gerard Butler as the Phantom of the Opera. *ducks to avoid rogue tomatoes*  But please understand that by writing this post I'm not at all trying to make an effort to negate the brilliance of other performances.  I definitely make no pretensions to say he's the best of the best, or anything of the sort.  For me at least, choosing a favorite phantom is just the old apples and oranges routine all over again.  Every adaptation brings its own strengths and weaknesses to the table, and there are way too many intricacies in any given performance to pick just favorite.  But that's one of the many beauties to The Phantom of the Opera.  The entire outlook or perspective on the story can turn a complete 180 with the slightest change to the way one syllable is sung... delightfully changeable and complex.  *le sigh*


Image from The Phantom of the Opera. #GerardButler pic.twitter.com/3yKq7LvMQNSome Phantom actors choose to play up the animal side of him, growling and howling on the roof scene when he's been "betrayed" by Christine, others work the insane angle, laughing and cackling at the chandelier fall all. the. way. down, still others emphasize the softer side of the depressed and lonely outsider that just wants somebody toohooo loooooovvve.... *ahem*  It's the combination and the interaction of these elements, along with a host of other details that add many layers to any given performance.

With all that in mind, I think Gerard Butler's performance deserves just as much unbiased analysis as the next actor's.  It's really easy to dismiss his performance as "horrific" and forget many of the really excellent points in it, and that's, well, just sad; because he does have a lot of really interesting, strong points I've not seen in any other performances.  I've also found a lot of interest in considering why he did go wrong where he did.  It wasn't perfect by any means, and that's... odd.

Let me 'splain...  No, there is too much.  Let me sum up.

I'm not going to get into all of the violent Butler hate out there.  Again, there's too much.  But generally speaking, I think it's fair to say that the overwhelmingly declared objection to his Phantom is that he wasn't a professional singer, he was awful, he fell flat, oh gosh look at that deformity (it's not even a deformity it looks like a bad sunburn, what happened there, ugh! he's so awful)...  But, for now, let's keep the deformity out of this.... that's a whole 'nother post.

     For the movie, Joel Shumacher and Andrew Lloyd Webber agreed during the early stages of development that the lead actors must sing their own parts.  No dubbing from other singers.  Shumacher also took issue with the fact that bringing in a professional theater cast would lead to the risk of alienating those uncultured swine movie-goers unfamiliar with "theater acting".  Theater acting is big and bold; it wouldn't be any substitute for the more subtle, intimate "film" acting that movies call for.  They wanted movie actors for movie roles.  Names like Kevin Spacey, John Travolta, Antonio Banderas, and even Meatloaf were thrown around (see Phans?  It could be much, much worse), but the rest is history.  Gerard Butler was chosen, and promptly threw himself into 10 months of vocal training to prepare for the role.  10 months...


     Boy, that elephant in the room is getting uncomfortable, no?  The flat notes.  Why on earth would the lead character in a prerecorded musical go flat?

     "'Why?' So simples, precious.  Rotten Butler! *gollum!!*  Should have gotten real Broadway singer instead of fiddling round with novices.  Stupid Shumachers! Stupid!!"

     Oh hi, it's you.. again.  Well... that's not exactly what I mean.  I'll concede, you do make a good point.  For such a renown musical, you would think they'd work as hard as possible to make sure every note is pristine.  Especially with the technology they had available to them to copy and paste good portions together.  Seems like it would be piece of cake, right?

     "Yeees precious!! Must be so tune-deaf, Butler, if they needs just give up after trying forever to get it perfects.  Failed, precious..."

     Maybe...  That's where things start getting a wee bit fishy for me.  It was around 2006, just a year or two after the "Phantom" movie was released, when my family and I went with a group to a recording studio for a tour.  It was a smaller, independently owned studio, but one of the most impressive things we took away from the tour was just how much fiddling they can do with a really, really rotten recording.  The tour guide grinned as he gave us a demonstration of what kind of tools studios have available to make anyone "sound like a million bucks" with ease.  The power of auto-tune is underestimated.  And with a production that hinges so heavily on everyone's voices sounding absolutely perfect, I don't doubt for an instant it was readily available to the Phantom team, and would have provided an easy fix for such a seemingly huge problem.  So, logically, the only conclusion I can come to is that the flat notes were actually...well... intentional.

     "Intentional??  Andrew Lloyd Webber wouldn't do that to us.  Webber understands good music!"

     I agree!  Andrew Lloyd Webber knows good music.  And I know this sounds completely anti-Webber, but if they could have fixed any of the issues, and they obviously didn't, then the only reasonable conclusion we can come to is that the final cut was exactly what the "powers that be" wanted, flat notes and all.  Now, why they wanted it?  That's something I've been puzzling over for some time... and I think the answer lies in a comparison of the two male protagonists in the film:


Picture from The Phantom of the Opera starring Gerard Butler, Emmy Rossum, Patrick Wilson, Miranda Richardson, Minnie Driver, Ciar�n Hinds, ...
Mr. Perfect.  (now he's on a horse)
     Patrick Wilson, who plays Raoul, is a professional singer.  His voice is smooth, silky, and sophisticated.  Giving just a moment to listen to his performance shows an absolutely flawless gentleman of a voice, much like the character he plays.  Raoul is the image of cool refinement, and like many of the arguments against him declare, he's not the wild, uber-passionate, romantic lover that the Phantom makes himself out to be.  He's not dangerous, he's not rough around the edges, he's shiny and pristine like a polished pearl.  His voice reflects that. (and it's gorrrgeous, precious)

     Gerard Butler, on the other hand, as we all know, is not a professional singer.  His voice is rough, gritty, and imperfect.  As Andrew Lloyd Webber said:
"We needed somebody who has a bit of rock and roll sensibility in him.  He's got to be a bit rough, a bit dangerous; not a conventional singer.  Christine is attracted to the Phantom because he's the right side of danger."
Mr. Not-so-perfect.  (no horse either. tsk.)
The conventional belief is that the Phantom's control over Christine stems from the near inhuman perfection and beauty of his voice.  But I think it's safe to say the Phantom would not have had any professional voice training; it wouldn't have been perfect.  His power over her, rather, comes from the unpolished, raw, artistic emotion that oozes out of him when he sings, and think that's what he teaches Christine to use in her own music.  He teaches her that good art isn't encumbered or constrained by convention, but driven by passion and instinct.  Well done art is wild, natural, and raw.  And though, to date, it's been an extremely unpopular one, I'm tempted to think that's the very statement the creators were making in leaving the imperfections intact.  It's the savage passion not the perfection, that makes his voice so bewitching to Christine.  (plus a little diabolical jedi mind trickery to boot)

At least that's how I see it.  The differences not only draw a dark line of contrast between the two men, but end up making a statement about the nature of art itself.  One that's definitely not seen as strongly in more polished stage versions.

That said, ultimately, I believe Gerard Butler pulled off what the creators set out for him to do.  His acting was fraught with the subtleties that film acting requires, the animal was plain to see, and even if they were touched up a bit, his falsetto notes are absolutely beautiful.  I'm not usually emotional during movies (with a few exceptions), but his moment during the roof scene always manages to blow me away.  The close, intimate point of view the film medium provides, paired with the wildly contrasting personas of the Phantom and Raoul, seen by the differences in "polish", really make for something vastly different from the stage version.  The film is an entirely different creature, and the same can be said for its cast.  And though I do love other casts and their renditions, I think this cast, Gerard Butler included, will always have a special place "inside my mind".

Wednesday, September 25, 2013

Bring Down the Chandelier!! - A Comparison Post


The real chandelier in the Palais Garnier
opera house.
     As mentioned previously, about 4 months ago my sister and I stumbled across a series of Phantom of the Opera stage performance comparison videos.  Each one lines up many different versions of critical (some not so) moments during the stage productions of "Phantom" from around the world.  I have no idea where all this footage is collected from, but it's vera vera interesting, and a vera quick way to lose an afternoon.

     Soo... for the next post, I thought it'd be fun to take a look at one of the much shorter, much more exciting comparison videos:  the grand chandelier crash!  For this breakdown, my sister, Rosy Danderfluff,  has offered her chandelier judging expertise, and between the two of us, we'll be giving each crash a rating of 1 to 5 red roses (with black satin ribbons, of course), 5 being the best and most fantabulous crash ever, "take me there now!", 1 being the equivalent of "My high school could do better than that; refund my money now and take me to Australia."
Without further ado...let it begin!!!

HAA HAAA HA!! AHH HA HA HA!!!!

(...... am I the only one who thinks it a little bothersome to have the Phantom laughing his head off when this happens?  Christine's just broken his heart in half, leading him to do this... wouldn't seem (to me at least) that he'd be in a giggly mood, even as a homicidal maniac...but I digress....)

Ok, seriously, here goes:

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



1) Japan, 1988  (1 out of 5 ----- 2 out of 5)
Ruby:  This one just sort of floats its way to the bottom of the stage... quite anticlimactic.  The delay in the applause makes me laugh a little bit too.
Rosy:  Erm....


2) Canadian Tour, 1991  (3 out of 5 ----- 3 out of 5)
Ruby:  Better!  For a second it almost looked like it had actually hit Christine before Raoul had time to nab her.  The audience likes it too, methinks.  Listen to that applause!
Rosy:

3) Netherlands, 1993  (3 out of 5 ----- 2 out of 5)
Ruby:  Hard to compare this one from that angle.  Love the flashing lights and the giant flash at the end though...
Rosy:

4) Austria, 1993  (2 out of 5 ----- 1 out of 5)
Ruby:  Neat to see some stagehands dashing from behind the curtain to grab the chandelier as it touched down, but overall very tame.  Meh.
Rosy:  That was pitiful!  (Rosy's back, yay!)

5) Los Angeles, 1993  (1 out of 5 ----- 1 out of 5)
Ruby:  This Phantom is completely out of control.  I don't think even I've ever laughed that hard.  The chandelier itself falls rather slowly as well, at least from this angle.
Rosy:  "Heeerree I cooommee.... just a second...."

6) Canada, 1995  (3 out of 5 ----- 3 out of 5)

Ruby:  I don't have much to say about this one, but it is nice to see the really tall height it's dropped from.  With that Tarzan shout I half expected to see the phantom swinging in on the chandelier.
Rosy:  Meh.

7) Hamburg, Germany, 1999  (5 out of 5 ----- 5 out of 5)
Ruby:  Now we're getting somewhere!!  This one makes me giggle like a school girl!  Lightning fast.  Was that scream from an actor or an audience member?
Rosy:  GEE WHIZ!!

8) Belgium, 2000  (4 out of 5 ----- 4 out of 5)
Ruby:  Whew!  No stagehands catching that runaway light fixture.  I think something exploded just as it swung in.  Wow!
Rosy:  Thaaat was close.  Nice catch, Raoul.

9) Mexico, 2000  (4 out of 5 ----- 3 out of 5)
Ruby:  I still can't quite enjoy that crazy laughing.  Great speed, bonus points for Raoul's stylish dancing with Christine off the stage.  Stay classy, Mexico.
Rosy:  Annnd twirl!  Now run.  I liked the downward drop, but it really lost power as it swung into the stage.  Kinda breaks the laws of physics.

10) Spain, 2002  (3 out of 5 ----- 2 out of 5)
Ruby:  Solid.
Rosy:  What's with all the camera angles?

11) Stuttgart, Germany, 2002  (4 out of 5 ----- 4 out of 5)
Ruby:  More German chandeliers, yay!  The Germans really play around with their maniacal laughing, makes me laugh too.  Again, great speed, but the slow down into the stage was extremely apparent.  I know the actors need a fighting chance to survive the evening, but I'll have to give this one 4 out of 5.
Rosy:  Is he yelling "Freedom!"??

12) Hungary, 2003  (3 out of 5 ----- 3 out of 5)
Ruby:  What just happened??  Different staging very disorienting, much.
Rosy:  Ditto...  What's with the tiny plume of smoke?  *poof*

13) World Tour  (3 out of 5 ----- 3 out of 5)
Ruby:  Okay, I know a tour must be tricky to stage a crash on, but that seemed very short lived.  Kudos for trying, but, for me it's just a 3 out of 5.
Rosy:  Very mechanically jerky at first, but it smoothed out towards the end.

14) Essen, Germany, 2005  (3 out of 5 ----- 2 out of 5)
Ruby:  Maybe it's the distance, but this one definitely didn't seem as fast as the other German productions.  I thought you were different, Germany.  *sniuI really did.
Rosy:  Freedom!!!!!

15) London, 2006  (3 out of 5 ----- 2 out of 5)
Ruby:  Kind of hard to tell from so close up, but the detail on the chandelier is lovely.
Rosy:

16) Las Vegas, 2006  (5 out of 5 ----- 5 out of 5)
Ruby:  Now this one is really interesting.  In the Las Vegas production they've inserted the chandelier crash into the Don Juan scene, just after Christine rips off his mask.  Much like the movie, yes?  No crazy laughing, just a "BRING DOWN THE CHANDELIER!!!" + Great BIG chandelier + vertical drop, no swinging to bother with + flashing lights and blackout just as it's about to hit the crowd = Muahahaha!!!  Priceless (in all seriousness though, did he bring it down with magical powers or something? how does that work?)
Rosy:  YES!!!!  Acting was a bit overwrought, but come on!!

17) Broadway, 2007  (1 out of 5 ----- 1 out of 5)
Ruby:  Can't compare to the others, sorry.  Too slow.
Rosy:  Big, but not fast enough.

18) Poland, 2008  (5 out of 5 ----- 4 out of 5)
Ruby:  I don't get the electrical sparks (I thought this was before the remodel?), but the crackling/crashing noises + sparks flying EVERYWHERE + another BIG chandelier + flashing lights and blackout = Fantabuloso!  Especially with the sound and lighting effects
Rosy:  Crashing crystals, awesome!  Don't like da sparks.  Not realistic.

(Editor's note:  Sparks could theoretically occur if the flames in the candles came into anything flamable, like, say, certain kinds of paint or decoration, right?  Maybe I'm wrong on that, dunno)

19) US Tour, 2010  (1 out of 5 ----- 1 out of 5)
Ruby:  Boy, shame about the tours.  I think they really struggle to get an impressive chandelier crash while on the road.
Rosy:  It's too eeassy.. this is too eaasssyy.

20) 25th Anniversary Concert, 2011  (3 out of 5 ----- 2 out of 5)
Ruby:  This one is tricky.  Because of the Royal Albert Hall location, I imagine it was going to be practically impossible to get a swinging chandelier this time round.  What they were able to accomplish was fantastic with the limitations in mind.  Sound effects and fireworks really are the way to go when livening up a crash.  But, at least in my book, I'd rather see a pitifully slow chandelier swinging crash than have none at all.  Maybe strobing the lights in addition to the sparks and noise would have added that perfect touch and element of unknown.
Rosy: Really?

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

     Overall...  I think we both agree the Hamburg and Las Vegas productions were our favorites... though Poland does offer a lot of new and exciting special effects.  I think having the lights flashing on and off, leaving the audience in the dark definitely helps to add a little bit of panic to the situation.  If we can't see what's going on, things get much, much scarier.

     The unknown element can be absolutely terrifying when used correctly (let alone when you have a one ton lighting fixture hurtling toward you at top speed *cough*).  Not knowing what we're up against, or not being able to size up our enemies, so to speak.  I'd even argue that's why so many of the most scary villains and monsters out there are hardly ever seen, be it the weeping angels, leprechauns (don't ask), the oods, or those creepy little dudes in "Don't be Afraid of the Dark".  The Phantom himself makes full use of shadows and mirrors in order not to be seen, to be an unknown; so it's really neat to see productions making use of that same element of mystery and blindness to smooth out rough patches and unimpressive speeds in the chandelier crash.  Anyway, that's my spiel, and I'm sticking to it.  More strobes, please!!

I really wanted to do this post to see what others thought!  What was your favorite(s) crash?  Plan to go to Germany anytime soon? (kidding. kidding.)  Any least favorites?  What do you think of the maniacal Phantom giggle fit?  The comment monster is hungry.

Tuesday, September 24, 2013

I've Got a Little List... "Phantom of the Opera" Links of Various Kinds

From http://icecreamrazorblades.tumblr.com/page/3    Phantom

     Heya!  For this evening, in honor of Celebrate Musicals week, I've collected a few websites, videos, and articles on all things Phantom of the Opera.  Funny what sort of stuff you come across on the internet.....


1. The Complete Libretto (Stage)

In case you want to check some lyrics for any and all reasons.  Extreeemly useful for all your Phantom needs.

2. The Complete Libretto (Film Version)

Great for comparing versions!  This one comes from the same mother site as the stage libretto above.

I know a lot of Phans will have already seen it... but this kind of thing just has to be shared at these sort of things!  This music video for the "The Phantom of the Opera" single was released even before the stage version had debuted (if I remember correctly), even before they had kicked Steve Harley out of the Phantom role and replaced him with Michael Crawford.  All I can say is, this video doesn't help my ambivalence with Sarah Brightman, and I'll never bemoan Michael Crawford's voice again after this performance. *Shudder*

And what on earth is with the Egyptian costumes??

I guess I should have mentioned in the tag that my first exposure to the Phantom, in all likelihood, was probably, actually Wishbone.  The ending is a little bizarre on this one, but I guess they wanted to alter it for the kiddos.  Who knew a Jack Russell Terrier could make such a fabulous Raoul?  Great episode.


Can't remember for the life of me where we discovered this, but this is a great 20-minute-ish behind-the-scenes look at the production of the 25th Anniversary Concert.  The sheer magnitude of that production really hits you, watching this.  They talk a little bit about just how many costumes they had to ship to England from other countries' productions to accommodate the larger cast, and difficulties with choreographing all the members in this alien venue, and much, much more.  It's really neat to see some footage of rehearsals and back-stage mulling during the performance as well.

(4:45 Part 1 *croak*)
(John Owen Jones and Anthony Warlow @ 2:41 Part 2!)

 (5:20 Part 2- Tee hee)

(Katie Hall @ 6:21 Part 2!)  Apparently they actually used many of the cast members from previous runs in the smaller roles for this production.  Katie Hall cameos, John!!


I have no idea what the story is behind this cartoon, but it's exceedingly diverting.  I haven't read the Gaston Leroux novel, yet, but most of the comments on the YouTube page seem to indicate this actually plays very closely to the book.  After watching this cartoon, I can definitely see why some would think Raoul is a jerk-face.

7. Phantom Costume Site
This links to an in-depth collection of pictures and specs on Maria Bjornson's original "Phantom" costume design.  Loads of pictures of costumes from all around the world if you link through to the photo galleries attached.  Vera neat stuff.

8. Sarah Brightman and Antonio Banderas Singing "The Phantom of the Opera"

Waay back before the movie had even been formally "pulled together", Antonio Banderas had already spent a number of years in preparation for the leading role... but, as we all know, that never panned out.  I guess this is his consolation prize?  Thoughts?
(Plus Shipping and Handling)


Nice article on the Chandelier crash.


That's right!  You too can own a "Phantom of the Opera" crashing chandelier!  500 pounds of sheer metalic crystal-crusted, beaded, glory, built to fly up to the top of your theater at a rate of 4' per second.


I had been planning on linking to a number of Phantom "comparison videos" we've been enjoying, of late, but there really are far, far to many to post in one place... suffice to say there are a plethora of fantastic videos on YouTube comparing certain parts of various performances of the Phantom of the Opera.  Tremendous fun, and a great way to get a feel for how various actors differ from each other.  GlassPrism, on YouTube, has some of the most exhaustive comparison videos, even incorporating footage from other countries like Japan and Germany; very cool stuff.  Otherwise, just type "phantom of the opera comparison" into the YouTube search engine and have at it! =)

This is one of our favorites. *cough*

So... that's all I've got for now!  What do y'all think?  Have you found some neat Phantom-related things around the interweb?  Please do share!  (it's fun!)

Monday, September 23, 2013

"Celebrate Musicals Week" Tag

Phantom of the Opera     Sorry if that startled anyone!  I never do these things, but I just had to this time.  The pause button is up near the top left-hand corner, when you've recovered.

     Sooo.... both "Celebrate Musicals Week" and "A Tolkien Blog Party of Special Magnificence" have begun (go check em' out!)!  Still working on the lovely Tolkien tag Hamlette put out yesterday, but it should be up soon.  Till then, Miss Amy Dashwood's tag for Celebrate Musicals Week:

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

1.  What musical did you pick to "spotlight" this week and why?

     After much debate internal I on The Phantom of the Opera did decide.  I know a lot of others are spotlighting this one as well, so I was a wee bit hesitant at first.  But there's only so much that can be said about "Cats", annnd there's just so much more to look at with "Phantom".  I'm excited. =D

2.  How did you discover the musical you picked (hereinafter referred to as "your musical")?

     Our cousins introduced us to "Phantom" one evening on an aforementioned summer trip to the Outer Banks.  We had to go to bed before the movie finished its run, but what we did see left a very strong impression.  Later, when we had gotten a subscription to a music software, we picked up where we had left off.  The rest is history, I guess.

3.  If you had to pick three favorite songs from your musical, which ones would they be?

     The two duets between Christine and the two "heroes", All I Ask of You and The Phantom of the Opera contrast so much, I think it's really a neat example of the differences between each of their relationships with Christine.  (dysfunction on the port bow, y'all.  Erik on the horizon).... erm... and... the Wandering Child sequence.  My brain always explodes from all the feels during that one. (though "Wishing You Were Somehow Here Again" really primes the tear ducts for that one)

4.  What's your least favorite song from your musical?

     Does "No One Would Listen" count?  I guess not, since it never actually made it into the musical.  Ick.  I really can't choose a least favorite... but I guess I could say if one had to go from the musical, I'd probably eliminate "Poor Fool, He Makes Me Laugh".  The story could remain intact without that one.

5.  Who are your favorite characters (choose up to three)?

     Hee, that's a loaded question.  Just real quick, Raoul, Carlotta, and.... the monkey.  He's brilliant.

6.  Which versions of your musical have you seen/listened to, and which is your favorite?

     I've listened to the movie soundtrack (of course), the 25th 
Anniversary Concert, a number of snippets from bootlegs, and a portion of the original soundtrack.... and I have to confess, I'm quite the fan of the movie soundtrack, though the Matt Cammelle/Rachael Barrel(s) version is also a real favorite (look it up, why don't ya?  Yur in fur a treat!).  Annnnd I do like others as well, but that's a whole post in the makings.

7.   Is this your favorite musical of all time?  If not, what is?

     Yes'm.  Though this number does give it a run for its money.... In all seriousness, though, with Phantom, it's not just the (drop-dead absolutely gorgeous) music for me.  The story is simple but it's chock full of all sorts of allegorical and 
symbolic value that's always kept my family coming back for more.  Hopefully I'll get a chance to post on that later this week.  Stay tuned! 

8.   Which cast album/musical soundtrack in your collection do you listen to the most?

     Probably the movie version *ducks*

9.   What is your favorite costume from your musical?

     I love the Red Death costume from the stage version.  I don't know how that mask works, but it's amazing. Such a shame they didn't use it in the film, but the movie version looked pretty sweet too.

10.  If you could change anything about your musical, what would you change?

     Boy, that's a tricky one.... I guess it's always bothered me a bit that Raoul is so dim-witted sometimes, if he were a little smarter about the whole "final lair" maniac-coming-at-you-with-a-rope situation that would be nice.  Though!  It absolutely bugs me to no end that in the stage version when Erik says "turn your face away from the garish light of day" he pushes her face away from him.  He's not the garish light of day.  If anything, he should be pulling her face towards himself.  He sees himself as the antithesis of "day", so it only makes sense.

11.  Which role(s) would you most like to play in any musical, if you had the opportunity to do so on stage?

     Me!! Indeed, you must excuse me.  I could not act anything if you were to give me the world.  No, indeed, I cannot act.

12.  If you could choose one performer to play any part in your musical, who would you choose and which part would you have them play?

     I've wished I could see Anthony Warlow reprise his role as the Phantom (bootlegs are near impossible to find), but I'd also be vera vera curious to see what Nathan James, from "Superstar" could do with that role.

(Here's a few clips of Nathan, not the best examples of his incredible power and vocal range, but his other performances had some crazy dancers some might not care to see, proceed at your own level of caution. =))

13.  Do you consider yourself a musical theatre fan in general or do you just like a few musicals?

     I really didn't grow up with a great deal of knowledge of musical theater... so if you had asked me say, last year, I would have said "no, not really."  I only had a very tiny collection of favorites.  But, thanks to Anthony Warlow, I've been falling more and more into the bottomless pit that is musical theater, by way of Gilbert and Sullivan, and it's delicious, precious. All that said, I still have just a very small set of musicals I absolutely love.

14.  Are you tired of the word "musical" yet?

     Not as much as I am of the work "twerk," that's for sure.

15.  Turn your music playing device on shuffle (or utilize Pandora if you don't have one) and tell us the names of the first three show tunes that come up-- no cheating!  How do these rank on your favorites/most-listened-to list?

     1. "Wishing You Were Somehow Here Again" - Phantom of the Opera Deluxe Soundtrack
     2. "After Much Debate Internal" - Patience (D'Oyly Carte Opera Company)
     3. "So Please You, Sir, We Much Regret" - The Mikado (D'Oyle Carte Opera Company)

That's how they came up, and I think it's fair to say that's the right ranking, too! 

(Here, I have a note... good Gilbert and Sullivan can be rather tricky to find on the interweb; if you have a hard time warming up to some of the performances on you tube, don't write them off immediately, since performances vary tremendously.)

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

On that note... *ahem* maybe I'll post some of our favorite G&S this week for funsies.  Can't wait to see how this week's parties turn out, vera vera excited!  For CMW, I have a few "Phantom of the Opera" posts in the wing, and a little bit of other stuffs too.  Till then, rock (opera) on!