Saturday, October 5, 2013

Symbolism in The Phantom of the Opera


     I really appreciate and love the veritable plethora of social commentary, allegories, and symbolism in The Phantom of the Opera, particularly the plight of the mentally, criminally insane genius or even the power of manipulation.  But over the years this particular thread has been one I keep coming back to and building on.  I'm not inclined in the least to think this was an intentional allegory on the part of the creator(s) of book or musical, but it's definitely become part of the lasting appeal to Phantom of the Opera, for me, anyway.

Past the point of no return,  the Final Threshold...
Ominous, no?
First... a little back-story:

     Now, a certain relative of mine has always taken issue with the fact that, at least in the movie, Christine is one weak, passive gal, and either way she chooses between Raoul and Erik she cannot WIIINNN, *ahem*.....  In all seriousness, that either way she chooses between them, she's putting herself into the hands of an overbearing alpha-male that will never give her the freedom she truly needs to be happy.  (personally, I think Raoul's protective instinct pales in comparison to Erik's controlling and obsessive need for power over her, but that's just m.h.o)  So... as we delved deeper into POTO, we took particular care to listen to the lyrics for evidences of the true nature of Raoul and Erik's respective relationships with Christine.

     It must have been during one of those early listening sessions that our mom mentioned in passing how "All I Ask of You" is not exclusively a "Raoul and Christine" song, but one that paints a really beautiful picture of any marriage; one of love, support, and caring for/protecting each other.  Even if the song itself is a little one-sided, I think it's important to remember that Raoul is trying to comfort Christine and give his promises to help save her from the solitude and terror she's been trapped by.  That's when it occurred to me that Raoul had taken on the role of a savior to Christine, just as Christ has become our own savior from the darkness and solitude that we find ourselves trapped in, our shelter, our light.

The Phantom of the Opera     Raoul was, many years ago, Christine's childhood sweetheart (is that fair to say?), but since then they have been separated, and Christine has grown up.  But now that Christine's full potential is about to be realized, she finds herself enveloped by the Phantom's threatening shadow.  Like Christ, Raoul steps in and makes a declaration of his love and intention to save her from the isolating darkness she's fallen into.  He promises to free her from her fears, and guide her back into daylight from the nightmare.
No more talk of darkness,
Forget these wide-eyed fears.
I'm here, nothing can harm you -
My words will warm and calm you. 
Let me be your freedom,
Let daylight dry your tears.
I'm here, with you, beside you,
To guard you and to guide you...  
      The Phantom, on the other hand, wants to lead her into the nightmare.  Since she was a very little girl, he's been masquerading as an angel sent to her from her father (hmm), teaching her the methods of his dark, bewitching music.  But now he reveals himself to her in her own reflection (interesting), and lures her down to his lair.  Like the devil, he wants her to serve him.  He wills her to be "his mask" to the world; "his spirit and her voice in one combined."  He tells her to turn away from the daylight, "surrender to her darkest dreams", and let his "music" "secretly possess" or own her.
Sing, My Angel of Music... by *Luaprata91 on deviantART
Let your mind start a journey through a strange, new world!
Leave all thoughts of the world you knew before!
Let your soul take you where you long to be! 
Only then can you belong to me ... 
Floating, falling, sweet intoxication!
Touch me, trust me, savor each sensation!
Let the dream begin, let your darker side give in
To the power of the music that I write
The power of the music of the night...

     After the Buquet's murder, Christine finally sees the Phantom for the danger he is and accepts Raoul's offer to help.  But following a few months Phantom-free, the Phantom suddenly emerges and lays his final trap, the opera Don Juan Triumphant (Matt 23-24.)  Raoul then lays his own trap for the Phantom during the performance.  He encourages Christine to go through with the role in order to finally overcome the Phantom, but it's not an easy task.  It's going to take a great deal of courage, determination, and faith in Raoul's plan to win, just as we need to trust fully in our own savior to overcome the grip of sin on our lives.

    When we get to "Wishing You Were Somehow Here Again", Christine comes to the point where she realizes that, in order to escape the Phantom and move on in life, she has to finally let go of her past.  That tight grip the Phantom has on her stems firmly in her need for a father figure.  Ever since she first arrived in the opera house, he's taken advantage of that hole in her heart, much like evil takes hold and uses holes in our hearts against us.  And like Christine, we have to finally let go of our past and let salvation fill those holes in order to move on.

The Phantom of The Opera by ~LibertineM on deviantART
     Though there's a whole lot going on in the Final Lair that I might want to extrapolate on later, I'm just going to focus on the basics, here.  From this point of view, the Final Lair can be seen as a sort of final test for Christine.  She's challenged to be willing to give up life as she knows it for Raoul.  The point of no return.  Even though, ultimately, Christine may not be called on to actually sacrifice herself for him, she proves her dedication to the relationship by essentially resigning herself to do what it takes for Raoul, however much it costs.  It's then that the Phantom realizes that whatever control he might have had over her before is now gone.  Even if he did trap her in his dungeon for the rest of her life, she would always love Raoul more.  The Phantom's power is gone; so he lets her go, secure in the protection that true love has given her.

     In a weird way, The Phantom of the Opera can be seen as a sort of Christian salvation story.  Of course, there are other details that don't fit as snugly into that kind of plot (i.e. circus freak brought to the opera house by Madame Giry, the ring Christine gives Erik at the end, and the whole "Christine I loooove you" spiel.) I think these really tie in more with the mentally insane, human phantom point of view, and I do enjoy them separately as part of that story-line.  The two viewpoints intermingle so much throughout the plot that it's always very engaging to untangle while watching it.  The many ways you can look at The Phantom of the Opera, in its music, its libretto, and its plot are something that make me find something new every single time I watch or listen to it.  At the end of the day, I'm always left wondering  whether or not it really is a coincidence the main heroine is named "Christine".

6 comments:

Skye said...

I love this take on The Phantom of The Opera! I watched it when I was pretty young, and I still listen to the tracks from it, but I never considered that there was so much subtext. I feel like going back and watching it again now :)

Ruby Danderfluff said...

Hi Skye! We had a similar hiatus for a few years; really gives interesting perspective when you do go back, watching it with eyes that haven't seen it for a while. (even if you do know the soundtrack) Phantom is always worth a revisit! (at least in my book, but I guess that's fairly obvious)

Thanks for the kind words! Nice to meet you =)

Hamlette (Rachel) said...

Hmm -- intriguing parallels! I hadn't really noticed that aspect, but now that you point it out, it's pretty fitting. Nifty!

Ruby Danderfluff said...

I've been surprised at how well it seems to fit as well... Sometimes I wonder if it's just one of those "if you want to see it, and if you squint hard enough, there it is!" things, but it's been enjoyable to explore and analyse, purposeful or not. =P

Charity said...

Nice parallels. I've always seen it as a bit of an allegory as well -- more so about a man's descent into darkness (the Phantom).

Also... THANK YOU. Christine needs to abandon them both. Raoul basically patronizes her and calls her an idiot through half of it, since he thinks she's delusional about the Phantom, and Erik... well, we all know what his behavior is like. Christine really can't win with either one of them. Although... I like Erik a bit more. At least he's pathetic; Raoul has everything, which entitles him to act like a brat! ;)

Ruby Danderfluff said...

I can definitely see a man's descent, there. Very cool! (all the various allegorical perspectives on this story never cease to amaze me!)

To be entirely honest, I've never understood all the Raoul hate out there. He obviously has his doubts about the existence of a mystical opera ghost, but during "Prima Donna" he and Meg start to put two and two together. What he does see is that Christine is scared out of her wits by *something,* (perhaps a sadistic madman on the loose.) He doesn't dismiss her or her feelings; instead he offers to help her escape from whatever is haunting her. That doesn't seem patronizing or brattish to me.

Raoul is perfectly capable of listening to Christine, even when it doesn't make sense to him. He keeps quiet about the engagement - "I can only hope I'll understand in time." And... if you take the swordfight as canon (something I also struggle to do,) he even held off on killing Erik at Christine's request!

Again, he's not so arrogant as to suggest he can single-handedly save her from those fears. When it comes to the Don Juan performance he fully recognizes that there's nothing he can do to help, other than wait in the wings with the militia. He'll do all he possibly can, but he reminds her that, now, she has to face and fight her own monsters.

Of course, all of that is what I see in the Lloyd Webber production. I haven't gotten the chance to read the book yet; my understanding is that Raoul is pretty darn rotten in that medium! But judging the musical by its own merit, I struggle to think how a suitor could have acted any better given that situation.