Wednesday, June 4, 2014

The Classics Club: The Tragedy of Hamlet, Prince of Denmark by William Shakespeare


[A few nights ago, a group of our friends got together to read Hamlet out loud - a task which lasted until 12:30 pm and left our reader for the title character a wee bit hoarse (quite the wild night.)  According to The Classics Club's requirements, a blog review should follow such literature consumption.  So, I obey.]

The Story:

     In William Shakespeare's classic play, Hamlet, the Danish prince, Hamlet, learns that his father did not die accidentally, but was in fact murdered by Hamlet's uncle, Claudius.  The ghost of Hamlet's father relays this information and commands him to exact revenge for his uncle's actions.  But before Hamlet can do this, he must resolve his feelings for the fair Ophelia, his anger at his mother's marriage to Claudius, and his uncle's attempts on his life, all while contemplating the meaning of his existence and battling his apparent madness.

(Source)
     Much like The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, William Shakespeare's Hamlet is one of those works you can't escape in modern culture.  Its iconic "to be or not to be" soliloquy has been immortalized with endless examinations, reiterations, and parodies; Rosencrantz and Guildenstern have gotten shares of attention disproportionate to their relatively small roles;  and we've all been advised at one point or another with the now-nearly-cliche line "to thine own self be true."  But of all of Shakespeare's works, why has Hamlet in particular managed to stick so solidly in our collective psyche?  I'm still not positive, but Eric McMillan said it well his article on the play:  
"What is it about this play that appeals so deeply to [us?] I don't know.  It's all over the place, yet somehow intensely focused.  I could write an essay on any of a dozen themes found in Hamlet, but I can't seem to sum up what the play is about.  I'm not sure anyone can."
I think sometimes it's the vague literature, like this play, that touches us most.  When the author's purpose isn't immediately apparent, it allows us to search for and then run with whatever interpretation we favor best (either because it's most evident or most fulfilling to us individually.)  It forces us to really sink our teeth into the material and dig for solutions, rather than just coast through the performance.  And ultimately, we all come away with different little gems of thought.  There are thousands of perspectives and approaches you could take with this play; so it's no wonder people have had such a field day with it over the past four hundred plus years.  Not the only attraction, of course, but certainly one.

The Man:

     I really appreciate Hamlet's unique perspective towards his situation.  Dedicated to the one cause of avenging his father (I would suggest having shirked all other ambitions,) and with the added isolation that supposed insanity tends to create, he seems to view the world around him with a more contemplative eye, more like an audience member watching a play than an actor participating in it.  He's only got one goal, and doesn't seem to really care about the rest of life; but he'll study it for answers. He's intensely focused, yet also has his head way up in the philosophical clouds.  This makes for some fantastic dialogue and a great main character.
Hamlet with skull of childhood companion Yorick
(Source)

       There's some question as to whether Hamlet was actually mad or not, and I tend to think not.  To be sure, Hamlet acts very eccentrically in the presence of others, but whenever he's alone, his speeches show a very attentive, careful, intelligent person.  He tests Claudius himself, rather than blindly accepting the ghost's claims, and discusses what's going on around him with a great deal of insight and thoughtfulness.  Maybe the "madness" was simply a part of the plan to cleanly avenge his father's death?  It works well as a distraction from Hamlet's true motives (up until Claudius decides to give him the boot anyway,) allows him to easily make starkly honest, probing statements, and actually gives him a decent excuse if he ever needs to account for killing Claudius - the classic courtroom mental illness claim.  This is exactly the defense he uses against Laertes following Polonius' murder.

     Buuut, that's not to say Hamlet wasn't a little bit nutty in his obsession over exacting revenge.  Avenging his father becomes his one and only goal, eventually leading him to contemplate committing suicide  (I think) after it's been accomplished.  After all, he has nothing else to live for, and life's "slings and arrows" are now much too painful.  His father is dead, his mother is disloyal, he's ruined his public image, and he's given up his one love, Ophelia.  Here, I think Ophelia represents his hopes for a future.  In Act II, scene 1, he takes one final look and tears himself from her.  Then, after his contemplation of suicide, she appears again to remind him of how much he loved her; he responds that he "did love her once" but then insists she go and commit herself a nunnery (and so isolate herself from the aforementioned slings and arrows of rotten life.)  Likewise, he's committed himself to a sort of nunnery, foregoing his own life and future, and living it only for his father's memory.  Perhaps he did intend to ultimately "shuffle off [the] mortal coil."

The Bottom Line:

(Source)
     Before reading Hamlet, I had already seen three of its film adaptations starring Laurence Olivier (1948,)  Derek Jacobi (1980,) and David Tennant (2009,) and now I'm chomping at the bit to see others, and read more.  There's a lot more going on with this play dealing with a lot more themes and a lot more characters.  Just Claudius' and Gertrude's characters leave a lot to be untangled, let alone that of Laertes, Ophelia, Polonius, Horatio, Fortinbras, and yes, Rosencrantz and Guildenstern. There are a host of roads to travel down with Hamlet, and I can't wait to delve into those later on.  Even then, I'm still left gnawing on the time tested "to be or not to be" soliloquy, and its speaker.  Between countless performances, analyses, and text to compare, there's a lot of meat left on that bone even after some four hundred years.  It's complicated,  and downright beautiful.

Shakespeare rules.

3 comments:

Carissa (Regency Woman) said...

Ahhhhh, Hamlet. This is my absolute favorite of Shakespeare's plays, one I've read many times over, seen 7 or so film adaptations, and even 1 stage production. Every time I see it, I'm reminded of it's awesomeness!

Was Hamlet mad? I think no, at the beginning, but madness started to develop further into the play. For instance, why would Hamlet talk himself out of killing Claudius while he's praying? He's using Claudius' penitent behavior as some sort of strange excuse to not follow through on his plan. The next scene has him in his mother's chamber where he stabs Polonius through the tapestry, but how could he possibly have thought Claudius would make it upstairs so quickly? His brain wasn't clicking along at the proper pacing anymore, probably from pretending to be crazy compounded with his depression.

I also often ponder who in the world was standing on the bank of the river watching Ophelia drown? The story is told in great detail, so who watched the death. Was the Queen instructed on what to say? Were they simply coming up with some viable story to explain her death? Did someone kill her? I could see Claudius doing it because Ophelia's madness was starting to put him at risk.

My brain works in mysterious ways. But I'm so happy you got to read the play, Ruby. One of my favorite things is reading it out loud! Such a great experience!

Ruby Danderfluff said...

I suspect that the odd excuse for not killing Claudius while praying was at least in part due to the experience Hamlet has had with the ghost. After seeing dear old dad's ghost in so much pain, I'm sure the last thing Hamlet wanted was for Claudius to fly off to heaven scot-free while his inoccent father is left to suffer in Purgatory. But I'm, suspicious, too, that Hamlet did spiral a little bit into the insanity the more he played that part. He's completely manic in some of the later scenes (mother's chamber included. sheesh!) And, like you mention, compounded with his depression, it does make a lot of sense.

Still curious as to why Hamlet's mother couldn't see the ghost when it appeared in her chamber. Another site has also said that Denmark (and Hamlet) would have been protestant at the time (and England too, obviously.) So why would the ghost be in Purgatory, and why would Shakespeare include that info nugget? Strange. Not sure if this plays more into the theory that Shakespeare was a closet Catholic, or that the ghost is part of Hamlet's vengeance-minded imagination. Hamlet's mind would picture his unavenged father as tortured and in need of closure, mirroring the state of his own psyche at the time. It's all so deliciously puzzling.

Ooh, I like the way you think. We were wondering too why the description of Ophelia's death was so detailed, and could only chock it up to some peasant who didn't care, but a murder conspiracy is definitely an interesting thought. Hmmm.

7 films?? Wow, which one has been your favorite so far? I'm not sure which one to see next, they're all so tempting! =)

Hamlette (Rachel) said...

I love what you said here:

I think sometimes it's the vague literature, like this play, that touches us most.

Yes! Every time I read or watch Hamlet, it strikes a new chord with me. I find new themes, new nuances -- such a wonderful font of ideas and thoughts.

I lean toward the not-mad side of the is-Hamlet-mad question, though I think that sometimes going a bit mad can save a person from going fully mad -- that assuming an antic disposition and acting out some of his feelings in the process may have been how he saved himself from actual madness.

I've decided he tells Ophelia to go to a nunnery because he's trying to save her from the destruction he knows is going to happen in Elsinore, the unrest that would follow the death of a king if he succeeds, and from having to see him die if he fails. Just my take.

I've seen 11 productions, 2 of which I disliked, 8 of which I own because I like them well enough to want to revisit them. (I also own one version I haven't watched yet.) Only one of those productions was live, but it was a doozy! I so wish they would have filmed it -- I'd own several copies! I also own at least a dozen copies of the text because I love reading the textual criticisms included in various editions -- always something new to learn!

Denmark would have been Protestant when the play was written, but not when it was set -- it's based on historical events, after all.

In some retelling I read (I think it was Gertrude and Claudius by John Updike, but now I can't recall for sure), Gertrude killed Ophelia because Claudius was getting too interested in her, and Gertrude didn't want to lose him. It really is suspicious how she knows all those details about Ophelia's death. Yeah, it's practical -- having a big pond on a stage for us to see her drown in would be prohibitively difficult, so have someone tell it. But why Gertrude? Why not Horatio, who was supposed to be looking after Ophelia? He could say he'd just gotten there too late, here's how he found her.

Shakespeare rules, indeed.